Bhutan
is a sparsely populated land of some 700,000 inhabitants, spread
out over the inaccessible and inhospitable mountainous landscape
in miniature agrarian settlements. Within what essentially remains
a traditional framework, individual units come together to compose
a loosely linked social collage. A nation that collectively
appears so different - united by centralized political and religious
institutions and a common historical experience - possesses
immense domestic diversity. Bhutanese society centers on community
- a collection of lives interwoven in such a way that everyone
appears important, no one is invisible. Within distanced villages,
inclusive relations assume heightened intimacy, joining the
rich with the poor, the old with the young, women and men in
collective survival strategies. The prevailing social situation
is characterized by a long-established underlying stability.
In this sense it is somewhat atypical - underdeveloped, yet
essentially free from the major social problems associated with
poverty, disparity, unemployment and degradation.
The few major urban centers, relatively new occurrences,
are indicative of the fact that, although at a formative stage,
Bhutanese society is undergoing fundamental transformations.
Following the nation's entry into the modern world in the
early 1960s and ongoing development interventions, people
are experiencing significant alterations in the parameters
within which they exist. A basic communications network now
loosely links the country both internally and externally.
The relationship between centralized state and devolved society
is becoming more intimate. Modern infrastructures have much
improved the health status and broadened the skills base.
A range of new choices and opportunities has emerged, associated
with technological innovations and structural adjustments.
Whereas previously lives were heavily circumscribed and pretty
predictable, young schoolchildren now face an exciting though
uncertain future.
The traditional order is gradually making way for a period
of restless reformation. From inward looking to outward oriented,
communities are coalescing to form a national playing field.
With opportunity comes aspiration and ambition, as the savvy
and streetwise jostle for position within a partially formed
modern system. Hierarchies are developing around the center
related to relationships with multiple aspects of modernity,
the most significant and lasting associated with wealth. Whereas
more subtle evolutions are evident at the village level, towns
represent the primary arenas for the formation of a modern
Bhutanese society.
There is no guarantee that amidst the sweeping changes the
nation will retain its overall consistency. The process of
social reorganization involves a delicate balancing act, and
trends are surfacing that have the potential to disrupt a
steady transition. The population is growing and urbanization
is on the increase. Informal local arrangements are being
supplemented, substituted or simply eroded by the formal national
infrastructure. Certain inequalities are emerging in wealth
and status, between genders and regions. Instances of delinquency
are slowly on the increase, as some are finding themselves
outside mainstream arrangements. Benefiting from the host
of modernisms and caught in an optimistic whirlwind, popular
expectations are running well ahead of society's ability to
fulfill them. In the tricky and unpredictable state between
tradition and modernity, the nation and its citizens face
a series of unprecedented challenges.
The Bhutanese economy is significantly underdeveloped in
keeping with the Kingdom's late entry to the modern world.
Although there have been considerable socioeconomic changes
since the 1960s, the economy is still in its infancy. The
livelihoods of the majority of the population remain based
around traditional modes of production, namely subsistence
agriculture and petty barter trade. Infrastructural improvements
and technological inputs have encouraged the diversification
of production, the development of markets and the emergence
of a modern sector. The country has to date been able to generate
very acceptable growth rates, connected to the gradual strategic
exploitation of the natural resource base and the high initial
returns on the mobilization of technology. However, the relatively
small size of the predominantly trade-based modern private
sector indicates that there is a long way to go.
The state will continue to play a central role as Bhutan's
economy undergoes major structural transformations. As well
as the responsibilities for macroeconomic management and development
interventions, it is the principal resource owner, the leading
producer and the major domestic market. Much still depends
on the government's economic and broader development policies.
The approach adopted is encapsulated in the unifying concept
of Gross National Happiness, which emphasizes stability, balance
and equity across all dimensions. Aiming to protect the culture
and the environment and effect concomitant social and political
reforms, the modern sector has been very gradually opened
up. This is reflected in heavy market regulation and tight
investment rules. Furthermore, the prudent management of public
finance and external assistance has slowed immediate economic
change. However, the development of a modern private sector
is becoming of increasing importance to the maintenance of
sustained growth and the provision of suitable employment
opportunities.
Continued economic development is critical to successful
modernization. Towards this end Bhutan possesses some important
assets and some fundamental constraints. A well functioning
state system, committed to national advancement, is endeavoring
to create an effective enabling environment. Moreover, the
country currently possesses the considerable advantages of
a relatively small population and reasonably rich natural
resource base. However, the impoverishment of the surrounding
regions clearly alludes to some essential economic realities.
The Himalayan area at large lies at the extreme periphery
of the world economy and the modernization process has had
some not altogether beneficial repercussions, typified by
the failure to achieve sustained economic development. The
nature of Bhutanese agriculture means that the country is
not best placed to make a smooth agrarian transition, and
there is considerable risk of a dual economy emerging. Furthermore,
the modern sector, forced to compete predominantly on the
more competitive export market, is hindered by high labor
and transaction costs. The relatively slow response of the
private sector is indicative of the fact that the lucrative
accommodation of modern technologies and associated forms
of economic organization will be problematic. For the realization
of the long term objective of an economy based around "sophistication
and civilization" (Planning Commission (1999:94)), the
government lead and the private sector response will be of
critical importance.
|